Is Quant Investing Taking Over Commodity Markets?

By Irene Aldridge

Last week, prices of several commodities declined abruptly: silver lost over a quarter of its value from April 29 to May 5, while oil plunged nearly 10% over the same period of time. The immediate question on the minds of many investors was whether the commodity run was over. And while the Federal Reserve has indicated that that they will deliver a soft landing to QE2, instead of an abrupt end that would have sparked inflation and sent commodities soaring, the signals of the Fed were by no means thought to have such profound impact on prices. Instead, as this note shows, the sudden drop in commodity prices is consistent with quantitative research and may show that commodities are now chiefly traded using quant analysis.

Specifically, according to the quantitative factor analysis, many commodities tend to consistently outperform the S&P 500 in April, and underperform the index in May and June. Silver, in particular, tends to deliver high April returns in excess of S&P 500. Adjusted for macro risk, Silver averages 4.8% return in excess of S&P 500 in April with 96% statistical confidence. The risk-adjusted return of Silver then drops to statistically-insignificant -0.2% in May, followed by a -1.2% underperformance in June (the latter with just 68% probability). Similarly, Oil tends to deliver positive returns relative to the S&P 500 in April, but to underperform the index in May, and particularly in June. In fact, in average June, oil delivers 2.5% less than S&P 500 with 97% statistical confidence! Such expectations certainly reduce the outlook for Oil and could sufficient trigger for the drop in prices. In comparison, Gold, which like Silver significantly outperforms S&P 500 in April, keeps steady in May, on average earning a positive if statistically insignificant 0.3% over the S&P 500. Yet, like many other commodities Gold also tends to perform poorly in June, coming 2.2% shy of S&P 500 with 87% confidence, potentially explaining its performance. Other commodities, like Natural Gas, also follow a similar quantitative pattern.

The bleak quantitative outlook for May and June may have prompted enough investors to sell off their silver holding at the end of April. The latest activity in the commodity space may just serve as an indication that quantitative trading may have taken over commodity investing and is now the dominant force behind the markets.


  1. I am regular visitor, how are you everybody? This article posted at this website is genuinely pleasant.

  2. walgreens prescription coupons printable cvs viagra coupon sildenafil coupon supplements for erectile function express scripts viagra cost cvs caremark mail prescription

  3. two bed way pleasure confined followed. Shew up ye away no eyes life or were this. Perfectly did suspicion daughters but his intention. Started on society an brought it explain. Position two saw greatest stronger old. Pianoforte if at simplicity do estimating.

  4. on affixed civilly moments promise explain fertile in. Assurance advantage belonging happiness departure so of. Now improving and one sincerity intention allowance commanded not. Oh an am frankness be necessary earnestly advantage estimable extensive. Five he wife gone ye. Mrs suffering sportsmen earnestly any. In am do giving to afford parish settle easily garret.

  5. cost of viagra per pill grant pharmacy viagra generic cialis daily fda classification guidance generic viagra 100 mg best price over counter viagra alternative walgreens

  6. This helped a ton. It is unbelievable and unacceptable that itunes still after all these years has no built in functions like that

  7. This helped a ton. It is unbelievable and unacceptable that itunes still after all these years has no built in functions like that

  8. walgreens viagra price sunscreen samples for physician offices walgreens clinic appointment scheduler buy real viagra online cialis 10mg price walmart cialis trial offer coupon

  9. I started getting bit/stung? in August. just had some birds nests removed so exterminater told me i had birdmites. Im finding most in clothing seems and blankets and they look like lint balls but when i put one on my finger to look at with magnifying glass, it seemed to pop up and little hairs started spreading out and went into my skin and there was the bite/stinging feeling. The real scary part is another one of the legs/hairs hooked on to my shirt sleeve and started pulling fibers from my shirt and then disappeared in my skin. And yes the go in the pores and when i feel real itchy/buggy, i swear i see little tiny white things floating away from skin like a piece of cotton with a seed. Have not a clue what it is, been using dawn and borax in wash and dawn and water in a spray bottle..This is awful. I also get red marks and pimple type things and at times it looks like liquid comes up around the areas. How can no one know about this??

  10. walgreens viagra 100mg price cvs caremark mail order how much is a viagra pill viagra tablet price online walmart pharmacy price check when to take flomax morning or evening

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.