Aggressive HFT and Institutional Trading Activity – Who Leads Market Crashes?

Aggressive HFT and Institutional Trading Activity – Who Leads Market Crashes?

Most recent routs in the U.S. financial markets have prompted an outpouring of angst. Detractors of high-frequency trading (HFT) were particularly up in arms about the market downturn, which many of them blamed squarely on manipulation by HFT. Much of the debate about the role of HFT in the events of August 2015 crash as well as previous market crashes was largely based on speculation. This article introduces data-driven evidence about the sequence of events on August 24, 2015, a particularly bad Monday when the U.S. equity markets lost over 4% in a single day.

To understand the trading dynamics that led to a precipitous drop in prices on August 24, 2015, we use probabilistic estimates (shown accurate in tests) of aggressive HFT and institutional activity. These estimates, developed by our company, AbleMarkets, are based on our proprietary methodologies for tracking aggressive HFT as well as large institutions, such as pension funds and hedge funds, in the U.S. equities markets. To detect aggressive HFT and institutional flow, we use complicated data-intensive computer programs running on hundreds of servers at any one time. The programs use highly granular market data and apply proprietary data science techniques to extract trading profiles of entities behind observed market orders. Since we are using anonymous market data to develop our conclusions, we do not identify particular institutions behind the trades. For instance, we can say with a high degree of confidence that a particular market order was placed by a high-frequency firm, but do not point to whether the high-frequency trader in question was, for example, employed by Getco or Virtu. Similarly, we can point to orders placed by large institutions, but we do not identify institutions that may include CALPERS or the Harvard University Endowment.

Our company’s, AbleMarkets, analysis of trading on August 24, 2015, shows that while there were bursts of aggressive HFT activity during the sell-off, it was the institutional activity, not the HFT activity that led and dominated the sell-off. Specifically, the events have appeared to unfold as follows: institutions would sell particular securities, creating acute selling pressure in the markets. Aggressive HFTs would then step in and sell the market further, but only for a relatively short period of time.

Specifically, on August 24, 2015, aggressive HFT reached 50% by volume in several major stocks throughout the day. However, the proportion of aggressive HFTs alternated between HFT buyers and sellers. For instance, the proportion of aggressive HFT Sellers in the S&P500 ETF (NYSE:SPY) was 62% shortly after the market open. However, proportion of aggressive HFT quickly reversed to spike to 75% in aggressive HFT BUY trades in major U.S. equities, such as MMM, at 9:45 AM that same day. Following that, aggressive HFTs further reversed the buy streak and started selling around 10:20 AM on the same day, with aggressive HFT sellers accounting for 53% in MMM, for example. The dominance of aggressive
HFT sellers continued through 2:21 PM in equities such as V, GS and SPY, staying at about 55% by volume in these securities. Around 2:30 PM, aggressive HFTs became once again more prominent on the buy side of the limit order book, where they stayed until the market close at about 50% of trading volume initiated by market buy orders.

On the same day, August 24, 2015, institutional sellers reached 70% to 90% of trading volume at market open and at Noon in major U.S. equities such as V, GS and MMM. In other words, in stocks like V and GS, institutional sellers started the selloff before HFT sellers by an extensive period of time as well as an extensive volume of trades.

The results of our analysis make sense intuitively when the nature of HFT strategies is taken into account. By definition, HFT is very short-term in its outlook and does not sustain a prolonged sell-off. Instead, HFT strategies alternate buy and sell (long and short) positions throughout the day. While achieving high-frequency reversals of positions throughout the day, aggressive HFTs tend to be balanced in their buy and sell activity: market buy orders quickly follow market sells and vice versa. Aggressive HFTs avoid accumulating large positions, and, as a result, do not tend to be directional on any particular day.

On the other hand, trades of large institutions, such as pension funds, tend to be large (sometimes taking several days to process) and are uni-directional – selling or buying without much alternating. As a result, institutions are capable of impacting the markets much more than do aggressive HFTs.

Steve Krawciw is CEO of Irene Aldridge is Managing Director of Able Alpha Trading, LTD., and and author of High-Frequency Trading: A Practical Guide to Algorithmic Strategies and Trading Systems (2nd edition, Wiley, 2013).


  1. 全面提供樓宇按揭貸款計劃及優惠,不限物業種類及樓齡,免收入証明及繁複的審查程序。 極具透明度及彈性. 24小時批核. 法例認可放債人機構.一按、二按、轉按、加按?無任歡迎 上市公司經營,信心保證,立即申請! 度身訂做借貸計劃.

  2. 畏高?害怕公開演講?Samsung #BeFearless計劃以虛擬實境擊退恐懼 – STYLE-TIPS.COM 你最恐懼的是甚麼?要克服恐懼,就要面對它。Samsung推行#BeFearles…

  3. 通過水光療程抑制黑色素細胞生長的成分注射到真皮層,減少黑色素形成,淡化黑斑色素沉澱,從而達到美白祛斑的效果 療程特色 :可配搭多元化產品來量身訂做不同療​​程計算機化規格,操作方便,容易控制可調節進針深度,精準注射於目標的肌膚層 每針的注射劑量相等,達到均勻注射 一次平均5點注射,可縮短療程時間 採用31號細針頭,幾乎看不到入針點 降低疼痛、瘀血、腫脹及不適感 使用靈活度高,可複合式搭配針劑,量身訂製療程

  4. West Ham United forward Diafra Sakho will not face retrospective punishment from the FA after allegedly headbutting Luke Shaw.  United’s private view was that defender Shaw was a victim of an attack. Diafra Sakho won’t face FA action over alleged headbutt of Luke Shaw

  5. PETE JENSON AT THE RAMON SANCHEZ PIZJUAN: Barcelona were beaten 2-1 by Sevilla as Unai Emery ended an incredible 20-game run of never having beaten Barça. Sevilla 2-1 Barcelona: Terrible defending costs Luis Enrique’s side as Michael Krohn-Dehli and Vicente Iborra sink La Liga champions

  6. I went over this site and I think you have a lot of excellent info, saved to my bookmarks (:.

  7. Have you ever considered creating an ebook or guest authoring on other blogs? I have a blog centered on the same ideas you discuss and would really like to have you share some stories/information. I know my viewers would enjoy your work. If you’re even remotely interested, feel free to shoot me an email.

  8. I just added this to my favorites. I truly love reading your posts. Tyvm!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.